Mortgage fraud is a serious problem that has been receiving more attention in Canada. It affects not just the financial industry but also those who are trying to buy a home. For individuals who are already mortgage holders as well as prospective homeowners, it is mandatory to understand the subtleties of mortgage fraud. This blog seeks to provide information about mortgage fraud, including what it is, how it happens, how it affects people and the economy, and how to prevent falling victim.

Understanding Mortgage Fraud

A purposeful act of providing incorrect or misleading information on a mortgage application by an individual or group is known as mortgage fraud. Usually, the purpose of this dishonesty is to get a mortgage that the applicant would not be able to get under real circumstances or to get better conditions on the loan than they would have if real data had been provided. 

Among other dishonest activities, this type of fraud may involve inflating income levels, hiding liabilities, or altering property values. Frequently, the ultimate motivation for these actions is financial gain, which can be attained through dishonest means of gaining property ownership or by negotiating better financing arrangements that lower interest rates or payment amounts, which would negatively affect lenders and the larger financial market.

Types of Mortgage Fraud

There are several main types of mortgage fraud popular in Canada. Let’s discuss some of those.

1. Income Fraud

Income fraud involves an applicant exaggerating or inventing income sources to qualify for a mortgage loan they otherwise might not receive. This type of fraud can include fabricating employment details or inflating income levels on loan applications.

Example: A borrower claims to be self-employed with a high income but provides no documentation of this income. Instead, they forge tax returns and fake bank statements showing deposits from a non-existent company.

2. Occupancy Fraud

This type of fraud occurs when a borrower lies about how they intend to use the property. This is significant because lenders often offer lower interest rates for primary residences compared to investment properties due to the perceived lower risk of default.

Example: An individual applies for a mortgage, stating they will use the property as their primary residence to secure a lower interest rate. However, their true intention is to rent it out as an investment property.

3. Property Fraud

Property fraud involves misrepresenting information about the property or its value. This could mean providing false information about the condition of the property or manipulating the appraisal process to inflate the property’s value artificially.

Example: A seller colludes with an appraiser to inflate the value of a property significantly above its true market value. The buyer, misled by the fraudulent appraisal, applies for a mortgage that is much higher than the property’s real worth.

4. Identity Theft

Identity theft in the context of mortgage fraud involves using someone else’s personal information without their permission to apply for a mortgage. This can include stealing someone’s identity to create a credit profile attractive to lenders.

Example: A fraudster steals the identity of a person with excellent credit by obtaining their social security number and other personal details. Using this information, the fraudster successfully applies for a mortgage, leaving the victim unaware and potentially liable.

5. Straw Buyer Fraud

Occurs when a person with good credit is used to purchase a property on behalf of another individual who would not qualify for the mortgage on their own. The straw buyer’s name and credit history are used without their intention to occupy or manage the property.

Example: A real estate investor wants to purchase a property but has poor credit. They convince a friend with a good credit score to act as the “straw buyer” for the mortgage application. The friend agrees, thinking they are helping, but they are unknowingly committing fraud.

6. Appraisal Fraud

Appraisal fraud happens when a home’s appraised value is deliberately understated or overstated. Overstating a home’s value can lead to the lender issuing a mortgage for more than the property is worth while understating can be used in short sales to deceive the lender into agreeing to a sale for less than the mortgage value.

Example: An appraiser, in collusion with a borrower, overstates the value of a property to help the borrower obtain a mortgage that significantly exceeds the property’s true market value. This allows the borrower to gain access to larger amounts of money than they should rightfully be entitled to.

7. Employment Fraud

This involves presenting false information about one’s employment status or history. Unlike income fraud, which focuses on the amount of income, employment fraud might involve creating a fictitious employer or lying about one’s position to seem more financially stable.

Example: A borrower fabricates an employer, complete with a fake website and phone number, to prove employment stability and a steady income. They may even enlist friends to act as the employer during verification calls.

8. Foreclosure Fraud

Foreclosure fraud usually targets homeowners struggling with their mortgage payments. Scammers might promise to save the homeowner from foreclosure, often in exchange for an upfront fee, title transfer, or by having them sign documents without fully understanding the implications.

Example: A scam artist approaches a homeowner facing foreclosure, offering to help them keep their home in exchange for an upfront fee and the transfer of the deed, claiming it will be temporary. Instead, the scammer either disappears with the fee or uses the deed transfer to take ownership of the home.

9. Loan Modification Fraud

Similar to foreclosure fraud, this involves scammers promising to secure loan modifications for a fee without delivering on their promises. They often mimic official programs and services to appear legitimate.

Example: Homeowners struggling to meet their mortgage payments are contacted by a company that claims it can secure a government-approved loan modification for an upfront fee. Once the fee is paid, the promised assistance never materializes, and the homeowner is left in a worse financial situation.

Consequences of Mortgage Fraud

Mortgage fraud has far-reaching effects that go beyond the immediate financial and legal repercussions for those who engage in such fraudulent schemes. For example, when fraud causes defaults and foreclosures, the neighbourhood’s property values may drop, which will hurt honest homeowners by undermining their net worth and the stability of the community. 

Furthermore, lenders may tighten lending standards in response to losses incurred from fraudulent activity, which would make it harder for eligible consumers to obtain credit. This can therefore cause the housing market to slow down, which would have an impact on real estate sales, the building sector, and overall economic expansion.

All borrowers may be indirectly impacted by the greater scrutiny and regulatory procedures implemented to prevent mortgage fraud, which may result in longer processing delays and higher application fees. Mortgage fraud has a huge social impact as well since it erodes public faith in the real estate and financial industries, which are essential to stability and confidence in the economy.

Personal and Legal Consequences for Fraudsters

A fraudster’s legal status, financial stability, and personal life may all be negatively impacted when they are discovered to have committed mortgage fraud. This is what may occur:

  • Legal Consequences: The most immediate and obvious repercussion for committing mortgage fraud is facing legal action. This can range from charges of fraud, which is a criminal offence, to specific charges related to financial and property crimes. The severity of the punishment can vary depending on the magnitude of the fraud, including imprisonment, probation, and significant legal fees. In Canada, for instance, individuals found guilty of mortgage fraud can face up to 14 years in prison under the Criminal Code for fraud over $5,000.
  • Financial Penalties: Beyond potential restitution payments to victims, fraudsters can be subjected to hefty fines designed to penalize wrongful actions and deter future fraud. These fines can reach into the tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars, depending on the scale of the fraud and the jurisdiction in which it was committed.
  • Damage to Credit Scores: Being convicted of mortgage fraud can have a lasting impact on a fraudster’s credit score. This can make it difficult to secure loans in the future, obtain credit cards, or even rent housing, as their financial reliability is severely compromised. The stain on their credit report can last for several years, reflecting the serious nature of their crimes.
  • Professional Repercussions: For those in professions related to finance, real estate, or law, being caught and convicted for mortgage fraud can mean the end of their career in that field. They may lose professional licenses or certifications, be barred from holding certain positions, and face ostracization from professional networks and communities.
  • Personal and Social Impact: The stigma attached to being convicted of a crime, particularly one involving dishonesty and breach of trust like mortgage fraud, can strain personal relationships, leading to social isolation. The stress and shame associated with legal proceedings and public exposure can also have profound psychological effects.
  • Restrictions on Future Opportunities: A criminal record can limit future opportunities significantly. It can affect an individual’s ability to travel internationally, as some countries may deny entry to those with a criminal history. Additionally, it can impact eligibility for certain types of employment, especially positions that require handling of money or sensitive information.

Protecting Yourself from Mortgage Fraud

Being vigilant and aware is essential to preventing mortgage fraud. Here are a few self-defence techniques:

  • Comprehensive Record-keeping: Make sure all of the information you submit when applying for a mortgage is true and properly documented.
  • Verify Identity: Be wary of unsolicited mortgage proposals and make sure the person you give personal information to is who they say they are.
  • Professional Advice: Consult with respectable mortgage brokers or financial advisors.
  • Frequent Credit Checks: Keep a close eye on your credit record to spot any unauthorized activity.

The Role of Regulatory Bodies

In Canada, several regulatory bodies play a critical role in preventing mortgage fraud and protecting consumers. These include the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC), the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC), and provincial regulatory authorities. These organizations provide guidelines for lenders, offer resources for consumers, and enforce laws related to mortgage fraud.

Mortgage fraud is a significant concern within Canada’s housing market, with various forms of fraud posing risks to individuals and the economy. By understanding the types of mortgage fraud, recognizing the potential consequences, and employing strategies to protect themselves, Canadians can navigate the mortgage process more securely. Additionally, the role of regulatory bodies in enforcing laws and providing resources is vital in the fight against mortgage fraud, ensuring a stable and fair housing market for all.

Categories: Mortgage


Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder